Hi There! Is this Your First Time?

Did you know if you Register Now to access our FREE search tools including the ability to save listings and property searches? Did you know that you can bypass the search altogether and have listings sent directly to your email address? Check out our how-to page for more info.

2380 Bay St
SARASOTA, FL 34237

  • Price$450,450
  • Beds2
  • Baths1
  • SQ. Feet1,641
  • Acres0.14
  • Built1963

Key West-Style Florida Living in the Heart of Sarasota! Welcome home to this charming Florida retreat where vibrant Key West flair meets modern updates and comfort. Featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a versatile floor plan, this home offers flexibility to suit your lifestyle. The wood-paneled den makes a cozy third bedroom or guest space, while the front room can serve as a bright office or living room. The dining room could easily transform into an additional sitting area — with plenty of space to dine in the spacious kitchen. Enjoy approximately 1,650 sq. ft. under air, plus a 120 sq. ft. Florida Room that can be cooled by opening to the main home — perfect for relaxing or entertaining year-round. Recent Updates & Features New Roof (2025) – 10-year warranty New Storm Windows (2025) New Water Heater (2023) Re-roofed Flat Roof (2018) A/C (2016) New Laminate Floors & Fresh Interior Paint (2025) Electric & Plumbing Up to Date Termite Tented (2017) with ongoing pest control Outdoor Florida Lifestyle Step into a lush, tropical paradise surrounded by mature Florida landscaping — including a majestic banyan tree, hibiscus, shell ginger, giant spider lilies, yesterday-today-tomorrow plants, palms, bird of paradise, and even a pineapple patch. Relax in your hot tub on the back patio or enjoy coffee in the garden or under the banyan tree. Prime Location Located in a friendly, walkable neighborhood: Walk or bike to Bayfront Park, Payne Park, and the Legacy Trail 10-minute drive to Lido Beach or Siesta Key Beach Walk to downtown Sarasota, public schools, library, and city offices Grade A Public Schools No HOA and No Flood Zone Experience laid-back Key West charm with modern Florida convenience — your tropical oasis awaits!

Get in Touch for More Information about this Property
Call Us: 941-923-7777
Request Detailed Listing Sheet
Request a Showing Print this Listing
Essential Information
  • MLS® #A4670064
  • Price$450,450
  • Bedrooms2
  • Bathrooms1.00
  • Full Baths1
  • Square Footage1,641
  • Acres0.14
  • Year Built1963
  • TypeResidential
  • Sub-TypeSingle Family Residence
  • StatusActive
Amenities
  • ParkingDriveway
Exterior
  • Exterior FeaturesOther
  • RoofOther
  • FoundationSlab
Community Information
  • Address2380 Bay St
  • AreaSarasota
  • SubdivisionPOMS PARK 3
  • CitySARASOTA
  • CountySarasota
  • StateFL
  • Zip Code34237
Interior
  • Interior FeaturesOther
  • AppliancesOther
  • HeatingCentral, Electric
  • CoolingCentral Air
Additional Information
  • Days on Market35